Feb 07, 2017

Trophy Tales: A History of U.S. Eventing Awards – Horse of the Year

By Leslie Mintz - USEA Staff
The 1987 Horse of the Year, The Pirate ridden by Kerry Millikin.

The Horse of the Year title is often considered the most prestigious given out annually by the United States Eventing Association. Awarded to the horse who earns the most points during a single competition year, it honors the true star of the sport. A USEA (formally USCTA) Horse of the Year has been named since 1963 when Duck Soup, ridden by J. Gibson Semmes, was the inaugural winner of The Chronicle of the Horse Trophy presented by Alexander Mackay-Smith.

The Casar Memorial Trophy being awarded to Winsome Adante for the first time. Linda Wachmeister, Loris Henry and Kim Vinoski (Severson) pictured. USEA Archives Photo.

In 1987, the Casar Memorial Trophy was donated by Dr. and Mrs. David Goodman to honor their Trakehner stallion and became the new perpetual award for the Horse of the Year. Bred by the Goodmans at their Wonderland Farms in West Chester, Pa., Casar (Donauschimmer x Celana) was ridden by Bruce Davidson, Sr. After finding great success at the CCI* level, Casar severed his tendon sheath at just six-years-old and had to be put down due to complications. The Pirate, owned and ridden by Kerry Millikin became the first name inscribed on the trophy (pictured above). Named “The Pirate” because of his one blue eye, the 16.2 hand Irish gelding earned 120 points that year by winning the Open Intermediate at Virginia and Fair Hill and the CCIs at Kentucky and Chesterland. Millikin is now a renown sculptor having created many works for the USEA including the Hall of Fame trophies.

Winsome Adante and Kim Severson. StockImagesServices.com Photo.

Winsome Adante is still the only horse to appear on the list multiple times – having won the Horse of the Year award in 2001, 2002 and 2004. When Mighty Nice earned the title in 2016, he became the fourth horse Phillip Dutton rode to Horse of the Year status – tying Karen O’Connor for the most appearances on the list.

Three of the Horses of the Year have been further honored by being inducted into the prestigious Eventing Hall of Fame: Custom Made, Good Mixture and Winsome Adante.

Past Winners of the Horse of the Year

2016 – Mighty Nice (Phillip Dutton)

2015 – Mai Baum (Tamra Smith)

2014 – No Boundaries (Erin Sylvester)

2013 – RF Demeter (Marilyn Little)

2012 – Mr. Medicott (Karen O’Connor)

2011 – Ballynoe Castle RM (Buck Davidson)

2010 – Cambalda (Jennie Brannigan)

2009 – Fleeceworks Mystere du Val (Leslie Law)

2008 – Dobbin (Corinne Ashton)

2007 – Theodore O’Connor (Karen O’Connor)

2006 – Tru Luck (Phillip Dutton)

2005 – The Foreman (Phillip Dutton)

2004 – Winsome Adante (Kim Severson)

2003 – Windfall (Darren Chiaccha)

2002 – Winsome Adante (Kim Severson)

2001 – Winsome Adante (Kim Severson)

2000 – Prince Panache (Karen O’Connor)

1999 – Rattle and Hum (David O’Connor)

1998 – True Blue Girdwood (Phillip Dutton)

1997 – Lightfoot (David O’Connor)

1996 – Custom Made (David O’Connor)

1995 – Wexford (Lauren Hart)

1994 – King’s Revenge (Kelli McMullen Temple)

1993 – Sassy Reason (Stephen Bradley)

1992 – Patrona (Jil Walton)

1991 – Mr. Maxwell (Karen Lende)

1990 – Shannon (Michael Godfrey)

1989 – Macavity (Kelli McMullen)

1988 – Shelbourne (Nancy Guyotte)

1987 – The Pirate (Kerry Millikin)

1986 – Elsaik (Nina Fout)

1985 – Doctor Peaches (Bruce Davidson)

1984 – Tribonius (Peter Green)

1983 – Pilot Kid (Bruce Davidson)

1982 – Arbour Hill (Karen Reuter)

1981 – Silent Partner (Karen Stives)

1980 – Poltroon (Torrance Watkins)

1979 – York (Denny Emerson)

1978 – Boy Alejo (Barbara Newton)

1977 – Laurenson (J. Michael Plumb)

1976 – Comic Relief (Caroline Traviranus)

1975 – Golden Griffin (Bruce Davidson)

1974 – St. Finnbarr (James Gornall)

1973 – Cajun (Caroline Treviranus)

1972 – Paddy (Carol Hannum)

1971 – Good Mixture (Kevin Freeman)

1970 – Royal Imp (Charlotte Robson)

1969 – M’Lord Connelly (J. Michael Plumb)

1968 – West Country (Mason Phelps, Jr.)

1967 – Thunder Road (Karen McLaughlin)

1966 – Evening Mail (Sara G. Lord)

1965 – Johnny O (J. Michael Plumb)

1964 – Whispering Sam (Lee Troup)

1963 – Duck Soup (J. Gibson Semmes)

Follow along to see who will become the 2017 Horse of the Year here.

Aug 18, 2019 Education

OTTB Critique Presented by Athletux: Brush Dance

Bred and owned by Thomas Bateman Jr., Brush Dance (Dance with Ravens x Phyxius) found his way into prominent racing trainer Timothy Keefe’s barn, which is where he stayed throughout his short-lived racing career. “He was a sweet, athletic horse but just didn’t have much interest for racing,” Keefe said.

Aug 17, 2019 Education

Systemic Joint Products: Straight to the Blood Supply

It is easy to become overwhelmed by the choices when choosing among different joint products. There are FDA-approved injectable drugs, including those that are injected directly into the joint intra-articularly (IA), or as intravenous (IV) and intramuscular (IM) injections.

Aug 16, 2019 AEC

The Road to AEC: Getting to Know Each Other

In 2017, I started what was a year-long search to find that perfect eventing horse. I stumbled upon a sale ad for a beautiful (what looked like an Irish Sport Horse) eventer who had successfully competed through Training level. This horse was only about four hours from home and was also well-known by many people in our area. The next thing I knew, on October 27, I was traveling down to Elizabeth, Illinois to have a test ride on “The Chief.”

Aug 16, 2019 Profile

Featured Clinician: Tik Maynard

Tik Maynard’s unique equestrian resume has enabled him to successfully develop horses and riders through a teaching philosophy that instills confidence and sets pairs up for success regardless of end goals. A revered natural horsemanship and eventing trainer, Maynard’s career with horses has evolved from experiences for the betterment of horse and rider relationships.

Official Corporate Sponsors of the USEA

Official Outerwear of the USEA

Official Supplement Feeding System of the USEA

Official Forage of the USEA

Official Riding Helmet of the USEA

Official Feed of the USEA

Official Saddle of the USEA

Official Joint Therapy Treatment of the USEA

Official Equine Insurance of the USEA